Brew Batch #140 Southie v2.1

Using Imperial's B63 yeast, this version of Southie got chewed up! A beautiful medium brown with some garnet highlights and an FG 1.004-0.001 @57F. This is the batch where I would have found out about the other hydrometer being off fo sho'. So the question is do I go with my missed OG of 1.083 or my expected 1.096 on this overnight mash. My gut tells me this one landed where it should have just like Reinke's did (actually overshot) so we should be sitting at about 12.2%. It's on gas and should be ready for a little sampling this weekend.